Office Hours
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking
Would you like to create a personalized quote?
Will Rentschler
Will Rentschler Ins Agency Inc
Office Hours
Address
Pensacola, FL 32501
Between 17th avenue and 12th avenue on East Cervantes Street
Office Hours
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking
Would you like to create a personalized quote?
Office Info
Office Info
Office Hours
-
Phone
(850) 433-4678 (850) 495-3391 -
Fax
(850) 270-0740
Languages
Insurance Products Offered
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Other Products
Banking
Office Info
Office Info
Office Hours
-
Phone
(850) 433-4678 (850) 495-3391 -
Fax
(850) 270-0740
Languages
Simple Insights®
Common rental scams and landlord frauds
Common rental scams and landlord frauds
Rental and landlord scams are more common than you think. Read this article to help avoid rental scams.
It's not the breed — any dog can bite
It's not the breed — any dog can bite
Dog bites can happen regardless of the breed, so use caution around canines.
Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself
Car maintenance tasks you can do yourself
To combat auto repair costs that keep climbing, some auto maintenance can be done at home. Here are ones that are usually do-it-yourself.
Viewing team member 1 of 19
Alyssa Hoover
Account Representative
License #G207896
Alyssa Hoover started with our agency in January of 2025. She was born and raised in Indiana. Alyssa is a Multiline Representative that is eager to help you to obtain the right policies! In her free time, you can find Alyssa reading a good book, getting outside and active, spending time with family, or playing with her cat (Nala) or puppy (Moose)!
Viewing team member 2 of 19
Bethany Hodges
Office Manager
License #W062364
Bethany Hodges has been employed at Will Rentschler State Farm since the beginning of its current location. However, her overall experience with the company dates back to 2011 making her the most experienced State Farm employee on staff. Her title is Operations manager, but you will not find any aspect of State Farm Insurance that she will not be able to assist you with. Her customer service skills are exceptional as anyone of her many regular customers would attest.
She resides only a mile away from the office. This means her home and neighborhood are the same as the vast majority of the customers she services. "Like a good neighbor" indeed.
Viewing team member 3 of 19
Blake Pablo
Multiple Line Representative
License #W721040
Viewing team member 4 of 19
Brandon Calabro
Account Manager
License #W951462
Brandon Calabro is started with our agency in January of 2023, and is originally from Navarre, FL. Brandon is an Account Manager, and is licensed to assist you with Auto, Home, Life, and Health in Florida. In his free time, he enjoys watching sports, playing video games and spending time with his family. Stop by our office and say hello to Brandon!
Viewing team member 5 of 19
Chase McLelland
Life/Health Products Representative
License #W499828
Chase, a multi-line representative at Will Rentschler State Farm moved to Pensacola, Fl from the great state of Alabama. With a background in financial services, Chase has done a great job helping customers with their auto, home, and life insurance. Chase enjoys watching Alabama football, spending time with his dog Jammer, and love of his life Stacey.
Viewing team member 6 of 19
Dylan Walton
Business Insurance Manager
License #W615845
Dylan, a multiline representative at Will Rentschler State Farm recently joined our team in September of 2022. While Dylan is new to our agency, he is not new to the insurance business. Dlyan has a background in commercial insurance where he spent the last 3 years improving upon his craft. Dylan enjoys helping our customers with the auto, life, home, and business insurance.
Viewing team member 7 of 19
AbiGail Flakes
Multiple Line Representative
License #W847280
AbiGail Flakes is a dedicated, experienced team member with years of invaluable knowledge in the insurance industry. With a passion for providing exceptional customer service, she has a deep understanding of State Farm's products, allowing her to assist you in making informed decisions to cover your assets and achieve your goals. She is committed to building long-lasting relationships by delivering insurance to fit your unique needs. In her free time, she enjoys reading and playing with her Corgi, Dunkin’
Viewing team member 8 of 19
Alonzo Moody
Account Representative
License #G077281
Viewing team member 9 of 19
Dylan White
Account Representative
License #G209583
Viewing team member 10 of 19
Eva Schroeder
Eva Lynn Schroeder, born in New Orleans and raised in Pensacola, Florida, is a skilled and highly organized assistant to Will. Her role involves managing schedules, coordinating tasks, and ensuring efficient operations with a structured approach. Beyond her professional life, Eva is a devoted mother and wife who relishes time on the beach for relaxation. As an enthusiastic baseball and softball mom, she actively supports her children’s sports activities, embracing her role with energy and commitment.
Viewing team member 11 of 19
Russell Siemer
License #G208283
Viewing team member 12 of 19
Shirlis Hadder
Customer Service Representative
License #G189668
Viewing team member 13 of 19
Hannah Hollingsworth
Multiple Line Representative
License #W764117
Hi, I’m Hannah! I’m originally from Memphis, TN. I graduated from the University of Mississippi with a degree in Accounting. Growing up I frequently visited the FL Panhandle and I decided to make it home. I love Pensacola! I’ve been in the financial industry for 10 years. As a Multi-line Representative, I’m licensed to assist you with Auto, Business, Health, Home and Life. During my free time I love playing sports, going to the beach, spending time with my family, cooking and reading. I’m passionate about helping my customers with their financial and insurance decisions and I look forward to working with you!
Viewing team member 14 of 19
Kaleb Prichard
Account Manager
License #W965475
Hello, I’m Kaleb! As a account manager, I’m licensed to assist you with Auto, Fire and Health in my home state of Florida. In my free time, I enjoy listening to music, traveling, and spending time with my family. Stop by our office in Pensacola to get started on a free insurance quote! I’m originally from Honolulu Hawaii, but now live in Pensacola, Florida.
Viewing team member 15 of 19
Katherine Cooper
Account Representative
License #G185880
Viewing team member 16 of 19
Kylie Powell
Customer Service Manager
License #W750058
Hi, I am Kylie! I am originally from Houston, Texas and I love Pensacola! I am licensed in auto, fire, home, commercial, and life insurance. My pride is helping people out each and every day. I have been in the insurance business for 10 years, and I am an Account manager at Will Rentschler State Farm. During my free time I enjoy going to the beach, spending time with friends, and making things with my Cricut!
Viewing team member 17 of 19
Mari Kleppinger
License #A159214
Mari works behind the scenes to make sure our staff is taken care of, and are guided by her years of State Farm wisdom. She started on 03/10/2007 – over 25 years ago. Mari is a former military brat but has lived here for so long, she’s a local. She graduated from the University of Florida – Go Gators! When she’s not working, she is asking her husband to cook seafood, traveling from one soccer practice to another with her daughter or just generally pestering her son.
Viewing team member 18 of 19
Michelle Riley
Account Representative
License #G201539
Hi! I am Michelle Riley, and I started with Will Rentschler’s StateFarm Agency in January of 2025. I am originally from the bluegrass state of Kentucky, but I moved to Perdido , Key Florida in the summer of 2021. I wanted to be closer to my parents, my brother, and the OCEAN! I love spending time at the beach collecting seashells and enjoying God’s beautiful creations! I just love being outdoors as much as possible! I am a multiline representative here at our agency. I am so excited to be able to assist you and your family on your insurance needs to plan a better future is key!
Viewing team member 19 of 19
Trayci Owens
License #G202216
Gulf Breeze, FL Full Time
Pensacola, FL Full Time
Pensacola, FL Full Time
Pensacola, FL Full Time
Pensacola, FL Full Time
Pensacola, FL Full Time
Pensacola, FL Part Time
Pensacola, FL Full Time
Gulf Breeze, FL Full Time
Pensacola, FL Part Time